There’s a (pot)hole in your privacy policy: Privacy Concerns in Canadian Problem-Reporting Websites

Oct 30, 2026·
Indrani Ray
,
Maria K. Wolters
Kami Vaniea
Kami Vaniea
· 0 min read
Abstract
City governments are leveraging digital platforms to increase engagement from the community and make services more accessible to their constituents. These platforms allow citizens to access non-emergency (a.k.a. 311) services to do things like report infrastructure problems, raise environmental concerns, and give feedback to city employees. These digital platforms often require users to supply personal information such as name, phone number, email, and address. We examine 13 Canadian cities to understand (i) what information citizens are required to provide across different service requests, (ii) what data is sent to known trackers and other third parties in the network traffic during a pothole repair request, and (iii) what data collection practices and protections are disclosed in privacy policies. Finally, we identify gaps in privacy policies. For example, no city lists all third parties citizen data is sent to. Although citizens expect transparency and responsible handling of their data from governments, we briefly discuss why this is difficult. The online nature of these systems places responsibility on developers for handling end-user data, but developers themselves might have difficulty understanding or limited visibility into data practices of third parties they integrate with. Our results highlight the need for more transparency around and understanding about third-party data sharing in e-governance.
Type
Publication
Conference on Sociotechnical Cybersecurity and Privacy
publication
Authors
Indrani Ray (she/her)
PhD student
Indrani Ray is a current PhD student at the University of Waterloo working on how people control access to their stuff.
Kami Vaniea
Authors
Kami Vaniea (she/her)
Associate Professor

I am an Associate Professor at the University of Waterloo’s Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering (ECE) where I head the Technology Usability Lab in Privacy and Security (TULiPS). The goal of my research is to make security and privacy technologies more accessible for a wide range of users including end users, developers, and system administrators. I believe that technology should support people in their activities. My recent projects include topics like patch management, developer-centered privacy, phishing, online anonymity, smart speaker privacy, and privacy on social media.

Research Toics: Access Control · Phishing · Privacy · Software Updates · Smart Speakers · Developer-Centered Privacy · Authentication

Affiliations: at the University of Waterloo and University of Edinburgh: