Multi-User Smart Speakers - A Narrative Review of Concerns and Problematic Interactions
Apr 1, 2023·,
,·
0 min read
Nicole Meng-Schneider
Rabia Yasa Kostas
Kami Vaniea
Maria K Wolters
Abstract
Smart speakers in multi-user spaces, such as Amazon Echos, introduce risks to both owners and anyone sharing the space. They store voice recordings of user requests, and anyone in range can potentially interact with the device. As smart speakers are usually bound to a single account, despite being shareable by design, it introduces potential tensions between users. We systematically searched the literature for findings on concerns and scenarios in which problems may arise and synthesised the resulting 20 papers in a narrative review. Owners were concerned about other users’, potentially malicious, interactions, device faults, and third party sharing. In contrast, bystanders worried about “being listened” to and a lack of awareness and protections. Our findings show a clear gap in literature on the privacy concerns of regular and incidental secondary users of smart speakers.
Type
Publication
In Extended Abstracts of the 2023 CHI Conference on Human Factors in Computing Systems

Authors
Kami Vaniea
(she/her)
Associate Professor
I am an Associate Professor at the University of Waterloo’s Department of Electrical and Computer Engineering (ECE) where I head the Technology Usability Lab in Privacy and Security (TULiPS). The goal of my research is to make security and privacy technologies more accessible for a wide range of users including end users, developers, and system administrators. I believe that technology should support people in their activities. My recent projects include topics like patch management, developer-centered privacy, phishing, online anonymity, smart speaker privacy, and privacy on social media.